Dear Czech friends: I apologise for our Brexit

Monday, June 27

Dear Czech friends: I apologise for our Brexit

 


"This is an event like the fall of the Wall." That's what my friend Marco wrote to me about Brexit. He and I have been friends since 1994, and would never have found ourselves in Prague had it not been for the fall of the Wall.


 The fall of the Wall was a great thing. There is nothing great about Brexit. Those in Britain who believe they are 'getting their country back' have believed a fairy tale. They cannot even agree what it means, but when I listen to them describing it, I don't like the sound of what they describe. It does not sound like the Britain I was proud to grow up in.

Unfortunately Brexit isn't just a British issue. The consequences will affect all of Europe, including the Czech Republic. Unscrupulous politicians in Britain have used it to gain power for themselves and push their political agenda. Similar politicians will try to do the same here and across Europe.

So it might help if I offer my analysis of why Britain voted Brexit. Of course there are many professional writers who might do this better, but maybe I offer a different perspective; that of someone who moved away, but stayed in touch. In particular, for months I argued about Brexit on an internet forum with my "tribe"; those who support the same football team, but in every other respect are different, coming from all kinds of occupations and social class. It was a mixture of qualitative and "quantitative" research, including, finally, a poll of voting intentions. Over 800 people took part and the result was 53-47 for Remain. It too was wrong.

There is one factor to point about the UK straight away. When I left, in 1993, it was already a crowded island. 54 million lived there. It has now increased to 65 million, an increase of more than the entire population of the Czech Republic. This put great strain on the infrastructure: the health service (NHS), the transport system, schools and housing. It is the fault of successive governments that they failed to invest in the infrastructure; but it was inevitably the poorer people, and  poorer parts of the country, which felt the consequences most. In addition when big waves of migrants came, they tended to settle in the same places, naturally. Many of them could only afford to live in the poorer areas too.

But the British have always had a problem with being "European". Even in my old advertising agency, containing some brilliant minds, nobody seemed to be as interested as I was in what was happening in November 1989. When the Wall fell, and I started talking about moving to one of the new DDB offices which would be opening, people thought I had gone mad. In the optimism of the early 90s, some of my ex colleagues tried to get involved within DDB Europe, trying to teach the skills and benefits of account planning. But when they were not immediately welcomed with open arms, they quickly retreated back to London where they felt appreciated. That was the period when Skoda's UK management insisted there must be a British advertising campaign for the brand. It was brilliant, but initially in Wolfsburg it nearly caused apoplexy among the VW management - until they saw the sales figures.

In the background there always seemed to be some politicians who did not like the EU. Nearly all were from the Conservative party, but obviously conservative in character; the type of Brits who do not feel comfortable in Europe, seem surprised that people there don't speak English, and do eat strange food. One such was a Member of Parliament called Bill Cash. He was obsessed with the EU, and Sky TV gave him lots of air time. My wife used to burst out laughing the moment his face appeared on screen. Then Tony Blair and New Labour came to power, and he disappeared from view. Cool Britannia was doing well, and immigrants were needed. Blair felt confident enough to allow Czechs and Poles free movement from the first day of accession to the EU.

After the 2008 crisis, people looked for some scapegoats. The bankers would have deserved to be the scapegoats but somehow got away without punishment. Meanwhile Romania and Bulgaria joined the EU and many of them headed to the UK, just when the country was struggling with recession. This created a fertile political ground for UKIP, led by Nigel Farage. He was Bill Cash with charisma. The EU was the scapegoat and immigration was the problem.

David Cameron, the Prime Minister since 2010,  had to confront the problem that many of his own MPs were Eurosceptic - and they now had the choice of defecting to UKIP. In trying to show them that he was going to be "tough" in Brussels, he made a fatal mistake. In 2009, he withdrew the Conservatives in the European Parliament from the big bloc of centre right parties (EPP-ED) which included Merkel's CDU. He set up a new more right wing bloc. His partner in this was none other than Mirek Topolanek and ODS, and they were soon joined by PiS of Poland. What do you suppose Angela Merkel thought of that? Do you think she and the others such as the Dutch had forgotten this, when Cameron came begging for concessions for Britain last year? He had already committed himself to a referendum. He declared himself satisfied with his "concessions" and pledged to campaign to Remain in the EU. But I never felt his concessions would be enough to satisfy the "Eurosceptics", because immigration was their main theme and there was nothing new that would allow the UK to stop EU citizens from arriving.

The problem with arguing for remaining in the EU is that it is not easy to summarise, and turn into political slogans. By comparison "Take back control" sounds very alluring.

Cameron gave his ministers freedom to campaign as they wished, but was still dismayed when Boris Johnson and Michael Gove decided to campaign for Brexit. In Johnson's case in particular the choice was driven purely by personal ambition. He knows how to make people like him. But neither he nor Gove could lay out a clear vision of what exactly a Brexit would look like. In the early days, it seemed that Johnson thought we could scare the EU into further concessions, and there would be no need for Brexit at all. But he quickly backtracked, and pretended he never said it. Typical of the man. Otherwise they had no common policy. In particular they could not explain whether or not we would stay in the Single Market. Norway and Switzerland are in it, despite not being in the EU, because they need it for economic health. But in return they must accept free movement of labour and many EU regulations. If the UK wants a "Norway" relationship with the EU there would be no new restrictions on migration from the EU. In the early weeks of the campaign it was clear that Brexit was losing the argument on the economics so it just focused on two things;  the immigration problem (without being clear about the answer to it), and the alleged amount of money Britain would save by not sending money to the EU. It  grossly exaggerated the amount , and claimed the money would be spent on the NHS. Not enough people noticed that Gove and Johnson are idealogically opposed to the principle of the NHS. Gove had previously argued that it should be privatized.

Many of the people who were susceptible to these simplistic arguments were natural supporters of the Labour Party. But this party had voted as leader a controversial veteran socialist who clearly did not really believe in the EU. His almost invisible support for Remain has now caused a rebellion within his own party, and he will probably lose his position as leader. Too late.

Cameron made two more mistakes before the referendum. There is a ridiculous rule that British citizens lose their right to vote if they leave the country for more than 15 years. He resolved to change it, but did not push it through in time for the referendum. I think that lost around 300-500,000 votes for Remain. There was also a demand to lower the voting age to 16. He ignored it.

Even on the day of the election it seemed that a narrow win for Remain was the likely result. In the event the main Remain support came from London, Scotland and Northern Ireland. Further analysis showed that the support was highest among the young and best-educated. The oldest and least well - educated were those that bought the Brexit lies.

The next day, David Cameron effectively resigned. It was noticeable that this shocked the Brexiteers in his own party. Slowly the impression emerged that Gove and Johnson had never really expected to win, and had no real plan for the next steps. I think they expected to become the puppet-masters with Cameron dancing on their strings. Cameron was not going to accept that, and I respect him for stepping down, even though his many mistakes have brought us to this grievous situation.

There is no space here for me to set out in more detail why I believe the UK should have voted to Remain, and why I believe in the EU. Nor is it yet easy to speculate on what happens next. But to any Czech friends who may be thinking that "Czechit" might be a good idea, I would ask you to think about these things:

-       the UK is a net contributor to the EU. The Czech Republic is a net beneficiary

-       the UK is currently absorbing around 150,000 migrants a year from other EU countries. I doubt there is net migration at all into CZ from the EU

-       Britain does have trade with many other countries, whereas CZ is very focused on Germany

-       While I doubt the UK can negotiate any special deal with the EU, it certainly has more chance of doing so than CZ has

-       Putin likes Brexit. Very few UK citizens understood why, or cared. I am sure Czechs know better than

 

In the meantime I see nothing but threats to our economic and political security as a result of Brexit. By 'our', I mean us, in the Czech Republic. I am here thanks to the fall of the Wall, and the EU's influence in helping the Czech Republic return to its place in the heart of a democratic, peaceful Europe. I will now be applying for Czech citizenship. The "island monkeys" as the Germans call the Brits, can leave the EU if they want. I have no intention of doing so.

Comments (32)

  • 1
    Walterclody2020-08-07 22:13:44
    Знаете ли вы? Российская учёная показала, что проект «Новой Москвы» 1923 года воспроизводил план трёхвековой давности. Жизненный путь абсолютного большинства звёзд известен заранее. В Чехословакии и СССР был свой «поцелуй победы». Искусствоведы спорили, смирилась ли со скорой смертью неизлечимо больная женщина на картине русского художника, а она прожила ещё 37 лет. Зелёный чай может быть розовым. 1хбет промокод при регистрации россия букмекерская контора париматч 1xbet регистрация вход
  • 2
    Walterclody2020-08-07 20:00:46
    Знаете ли вы? Роден назвал свои «Врата ада» напрямую, а его соотечественник только намекнул. Индонезийской закуской начиняют пирожки, посыпают рис и кладут в лапшу и супы. Андрогинный псевдоним не спас автора от расшифровки. Жену Генриха VIII на суде защищал посол Священной Римской империи. Английский крейсер ценой четырёх попаданий защитил конвой от немецкого рейдера. 1xbet без регистрации фонбет регистрация promokod fonbet ru зеркало для марафонбет
  • 3
    Annacon2020-07-21 22:16:33
    Доброе время суток! Бывает охота расслабиться и слушать песни кати кстати в тему, то есть в этом мне служит поддержкой музыка... за прослушиванием лучшие песни 2019 онлайн я могу быть много часов подряд Так оно песни с днем рождения детские скачать бесплатно при хорошем звуке делает своё дело и иностранная музыка тоже Всякий выбирает место где слушать песни онлайн, и я выбираю https://owen.ru/forum/album.php?albumid=100&attachmentid=48667 Основное достоинство этого аудио ресурса, что он не требует регистрации и смс Быть может вы знаете проект c слушать онлайн песни подряд? Благодарю! Теги: музыка негров, слушать музыку онлайн бесплатно 2019 без, песня через, песни ремикс скачать бесплатно mp3, онлайн песня ротару https://bit.ly/30cflmp песня птица https://bit.ly/3ftrIkm музыка регистрацию качестве
  • 4
    FraOmido2020-07-19 18:50:17
  • 5
    Jerryjem2020-07-09 13:27:40
    Знаете ли вы? Первая абсолютная чемпионка турнира Большого шлема похоронена в могиле для бедняков. Советские военные операторы на базе ленд-лизовского кинопулемёта и ППШ создали киноавтомат. Копенгагенский собор пришлось выстроить заново после визита англичан в 1807 году. Преподаватель нескольких университетов, попавший в сталинские лагеря, и там умудрился обучать математике на куске мыла. Владелец вернул похищенную картину Пикассо почтой, не найдя покупателей. arbeca
  • 6
    Jerryjem2020-07-09 11:06:36
    Знаете ли вы? Преподаватель нескольких университетов, попавший в сталинские лагеря, и там умудрился обучать математике на куске мыла. Первая председательница Верховного суда Татарии молчала по поводу своей службы в НКВД. Жизненный путь абсолютного большинства звёзд известен заранее. Китайскую пустыню засадили лесами и открыли там фешенебельный курорт. Бывший министр финансов удостоился высшей государственной награды за распространение знаний о психических расстройствах. arbeca
  • 7
    Jerryjem2020-07-09 07:21:48
    Знаете ли вы? Первая абсолютная чемпионка турнира Большого шлема похоронена в могиле для бедняков. В 1941 году в московскую «Писательскую роту» пришли добровольцами бывший вор и следователь ЧК. Иракский физрук получил мировую известность под псевдонимом «ангел смерти». «Голова крестьянина» хранилась в доме у немецкой актрисы. Американская энциклопедия включила в себя десятки статей о вымышленных людях, якобы связанных с Латинской Америкой. http://www.arbeca.net/
  • 8
    Jerryjem2020-07-09 04:17:45
    Знаете ли вы? Российских легкоалетов могут сурово наказать за действия чиновников от спорта. Убийца с руками-клешнями избежал тюрьмы, но позже сам был убит. В 1941 году в московскую «Писательскую роту» пришли добровольцами бывший вор и следователь ЧК. В игре про выгорание отражён печальный личный опыт главного разработчика. Иногда для поддержки экономики деньги «разбрасывают с вертолёта». arbeca
  • 9
    AndreSkime2020-07-07 05:37:43
  • 10
    AndreSkime2020-07-06 20:39:24
  • 11
    AndreSkime2020-07-03 16:49:39
  • 12
    RonRhymn2020-07-02 04:43:10
  • 13
    JamesTip2020-06-18 19:13:28
    Знаете ли вы? Сооснователь и глава Социал-демократической партии Великобритании стал бароном. Перечень имён может быть самостоятельным поэтическим жанром. В Чехословакии и СССР был свой «поцелуй победы». Карьера не помешала фарерскому футболисту играть в гандбол, записать три музыкальных альбома, издать пять книг и сняться в восьми фильмах. Команды тренера года АБА и НБА ни разу не стали в них финалистками. http://0pb8hx.com/
  • 14
    Youtubetomp3i69302020-06-04 16:43:39
    Hello folks, just came across this site and would like to post some handy website resource which might be help, thanks! The online YouTube to mp4 support all web browsers to Download YouTube to MP3 & MP4. y2mate website. Best free YouTube converter website. youtube mp3.Miglior YouTube libero per MP3/MP4 Strumento scarico Top ten image upscaler review. Best youtube video downloader of 2020. Best redfox review site.
  • 15
    Keepvid644t2020-05-06 03:24:51
    Hi my friends, I would like to share some handy online toos which might help, thanks! The Best YouTube to mp3 converter The Best YouTube to mp3 online for free. youtube converter YouTube MP3 JPG PDF 変換 Bestyoutubetomp3 online tools for APAC visitors. anydvd crack version and reviews. Support all web browsers to Download YouTube to MP3 & MP4
  • 16
    Keepvid552e2020-04-23 10:54:30
    Hi dear friens, I would like to share some handy online toos which might help, thanks! The Best YouTube to mp3 converter The Best YouTube to mp3 online for free. youtube converter YouTube MP3 JPG PDF 変換 Bestyoutubetomp3 online tools for APAC visitors. anydvd crack version and reviews. Support all web browsers to Download YouTube to MP3 & MP4
  • 17
    Keepvid322a2020-04-06 11:51:07
    Hi fellows, just came across your wonderful website and would like to post some free userful resource. The Best free online YouTube mp3 tools. New youtube converter website. The Best and stable YouTube video Downloader New youtube to mp3 website.
  • 18
    Keepvid137u2020-04-03 07:11:34
    Hello dear friens, I would like to introduce a handy online tool. The Best YouTube to mp4 downloader The Best YouTube downloader online for free. youtube converter YouTube to mp3 JPG PDF 変換 Bestyoutubetomp3 online tools for APAC visitors. Support all web browsers to Download YouTube to MP3 & MP4 MP3 is mainly for audio files, whereas MP4 is for multiple digital files. If you want to listen to music only, a tool that converts YouTube to MP3 is your choice. If you have enough space on your devices, you can download YouTube videos in MP4 format so that you can enjoy both music and videos. No matter which one you need, this tool is a good choice. You can download videos here and convert YouTube to MP3 to only enjoy the audio. This free online solution to YouTube download can assist you to download YouTube to MP3 and MP4. How to download from YouTube? Just give this tool a try.
  • 19
    MarilynBER2020-03-29 11:13:17
  • 20
    Williamimmug2020-03-06 18:08:40
    Online sports betting ,Online casino slots news at Jackpot Bet Online. All Word favorite Sportsbook, Racebook, and online Casino slots. Jackpot Bet Online - We have got your casino games, Bonuses, fast payouts, sports betting odds online. NFL Football betting, horse race wagering, online casino slots bets and more. Top Online casino sites list Redbet Casino AHTI Casino Online Casino King Playojo Casino LunaCasino Casino RedKings EUcasino FortuneJack Casino Diamond Reels Casino Prospect Hall Casino Foxy Casino Betway casino Spelautomater Casino Casino På Nett
  • 21
    Y2mateF4332020-03-05 03:49:34
    Hi there, just came across your post, really like your works! Would like to share some useful free website, hope you like it. Youtube Converter y2mate Youtube to mp3 Youtube to mp3 YouTube MP3 変換 Youtube to mp4
  • 22
    Peterzxu2020-03-01 18:19:44
    Free online word to pdf and pdf to word converter. This online PDF converter software can transform PDF documents to editable documents in Microsoft Word Doc format, which can provide higher quality than many other converters. When you use from PDF to Word you will conquer all the difficulties, and, it's Free. Hello folks, I like your posts, just to share a few free tool websites which might help. 2conv MP3 Youtube converter Youtube video downloader ytmp3 Y2mate Youtube to mp3 free video enhancer
  • 23
    BrianKab2020-02-20 02:51:00
    Online sports betting ,Online casino slots news at Jackpot Bet Online. All Word favorite Sportsbook, Racebook, and online Casino slots. Jackpot Bet Online - We have got your casino games, Bonuses, fast payouts, sports betting odds online. NFL Football betting, horse race wagering, online casino slots bets and more. Bet365 Bingo Gala Bingo Bet365 Casino 888sports Betting 888 Poker Partypoker Virgin Casino Redbet Casino Ladbrokes Poker Casino on Net Netent online casino Jaak casino Deluxino online casino Bet2u casino Tony Bet casino Top Tally casino Casiplay online casino Fruits4Real casino BetWinner casino 666 online casino
  • 24
    Ronalditaws2020-02-08 07:40:19
    GunsBet Casino ГансБет Казино Официальный сайт играть онлайн бесплатно или на деньги
  • 25
    GeraldDak2020-02-06 13:15:02
    Online sports betting ,Online casino slots news at Jackpot Bet Online. All Word favorite Sportsbook, Racebook, and online Casino slots. Jackpot Bet Online - We have got your casino games, Bonuses, fast payouts, sports betting odds online. NFL Football betting, horse race wagering, online casino slots bets and more. Online Casino slots & Sports betting Review AHTI Casino Online Casino King Playojo Casino LunaCasino Casino RedKings EUcasino FortuneJack Casino Diamond Reels Casino Prospect Hall Casino Foxy Casino Betway casino
  • 26
    ArleneMus2020-01-26 17:36:47
    Добрый день. Я Юля. Познакомлюсь с парнем для встречи. Приеду к тебе на район или встримся у меня. Живу недалеко. Мой сайт
  • 27
    Calvincheal2020-01-23 00:47:37
    herbal cat remedies https://alijuguetes.es/lorazepam-en-farmacia-pfz.php nausea natural remedies
  • 28
    Josephawaro2020-01-16 19:05:00
    Официальный сайт PlayAmo Casino - https://playamo.pro/
  • 29
    Brycemaf2020-01-08 07:30:21
    Представим, вы хозяин нового сайта, который имеет приятный стиль, удобную навигацию и полезную для посетителей рекламную информацию. Но до сих пор нет посетителей на сайте. Что делать? Те, кто имеют свой бизнес мы поможем вам создать веб сервис. Отмечено что, ни одно реальное либо виртуальное предприятие не может продвигаться независимо. Любой компании поставщика необходима содействие в приобретении известности, а во Глобальной сети без нее безусловно не обойтись из-за бурной конкуренции.Мы занимаемся разработкой пейджа. Мы готовы запустить хороший любой сайт в течение шести дней. Кроме оказания рабочих интернет-проектов, мы предоставляем обслуживание по тех. подмоги: своевременное продление хостинга и домена, добавление содержания на web-сайт, размещения известий. Наши услуги помогают вам стать лидером на необъятных просторах инета. продвижение сайтов в сша европе
  • 30
    viagra online2020-01-04 16:47:33
    viagra dosage viagra online viagra erection
  • 31
    Сontractorhix2020-01-03 16:43:48
    Inside restorations, General development-- services that are actually used through many associations in Manhattan. But our company stays the market innovator for many years. On our profile, a substantial amount of examples of collaboration with both people and also corporations. corporate interior design Premium Interior renovators are not just an investment, it is actually an assets that boosts the functionality and also convenience of any type of area - a cottage, workplace, condo, townhouse. To generate friendliness interior decoration skillfully and effectively, it is essential to make use of tested as well as extremely sound products that comply with all standards and specialized specifications. Yet the major subtlety is actually not also in the components, yet in just how as well as exactly how accurately they are actually used. And this is actually the work of the professionals. Expert skill-sets are an very vital circumstances. Merely through this method can company inner parts renovation be applied as planned. The business performs internal remodellings NY flats, homes, areas, managerial as well as industrial grounds in NY on a turn-key manner at very competitive costs. Depending on our company, you acquire Internal renovators New York City with a guarantee of premium quality, short due dates for repair work, dependability and also capability of internal services.
  • 32
    Jakob Mos2017-09-16 00:16:03
    Hey Richard, There is still The Commonwealth to be explored, just an observation from the other side of the ocean. Jakob

Add comment



Items marked with star (*) are required.